Fear-factor foods. You know what I’m talking about! Not weird or creepy foods. Just simple fruits and vegetables that you haven’t ever tried (or cooked with) because they intimidate the heck out of you.
Seems silly, right? Innocent fruits and veggies! Occasionally we glance, pause, and consider putting that produce item in our cart.
But then we think “what if the kids don’t like it?“… “really, do I even have time to experiment with a new veggie this week?!” … “it will just be a waste of money!”
Yeah, there’s always a reason to forgo and instead pick up the familiar: carrots, potatoes, cucumbers, lettuce. Hey, I’ve been there.
I’m still there. There are certain veg I still ignore, like daikon radish, kohlrabi, mizuna, arugula, and all things cabbage!

In my early vegan cooking days, one of those fear-factor vegetables was winter squash. They were so mysteriously unapproachable with their shapes, large size, and hard peels. I figured I’d need safety googles to tackle one!
Yet, winter squash are actually much easier (and more forgiving) than we first assume. At this point in my plant-based journey, I absolutely love winter squash. I buy several every week – and mostly eat them myself!

Besides recipes, I often eat cooked squash in daily lunch bowls during the fall and winter. They are hearty and nourishing, easy to prep (yes, easy!), and delicious.
Of course, I also love using winter squash in recipes, most often butternut squash soups. Today, I’m sharing one of my favorite recipes from Plant-Powered Families. It’s so darn easy to make!
But, before you click through to the recipe, I have a video for you about prepping winter squash. My favorite way to prep winter squash is to bake them up whole. Just a quick wash of the entire whole squash, then on to a baking sheet (lined with parchment paper).
Doesn’t matter the type of squash, no need to peel or cut. This saves a lot of grief trying to slice and chop these tough guys! However, if you do want to chop/cube squash for a recipe purpose, you can make it a lot easier on yourself – and I share some tips in the video below.
After watching, grab a butternut (or other dark orange) squash and enjoy this silky, comforting winter soup.
The secret to making this butternut squash soup especially luscious and creamy without oil? Not just the use of soaked cashews but also the roasting of the squash and the onions.
Roasting veggies whole is one of my new cooking secrets for infusing dishes with deep flavor without adding oil. (If you love the soup, also try my Mac-nificent in Plant-Powered Families).

To puree the soup, you can use an immersion blender, but I prefer a high-speed blender. I use a Blendtec. You can purchase any Blendtec (and accessories) and enjoy 20% off with Blendtec Coupon Code YAY-BLENDTEC through this link.
SMASHING Butternut Squash Soup
Ingredients
- 3- lb whole unpeeled butternut or other deep orange winter squash
- 1 large or 2 small whole unpeeled onions
- 2 cups water plus more, if desired, to thin
- 1/2 cup presoaked and drained raw cashews
- 1 tablespoon freshly squeezed lemon juice
- 1 teaspoon fresh rosemary see note
- 1 teaspoon sea salt
- 1/4 teaspoon cinnamon
- 1/8 teaspoon allspice
- 1 medium-large clove garlic
Instructions
- Preheat oven to 450°F. Line a baking sheet with parchment paper. Place the squash and onion on the prepared sheet and bake for an hour or longer, until the squash is completely tender when pierced through. (Baking time will vary depending on the size of the vegetables. If you use 2 smaller squash to total 3 pounds, they will cook quicker.) Remove squash and onion from oven and cut the squash lengthwise to accelerate cooling so you can handle. Meanwhile, add the water, cashews, lemon juice, rosemary, sea salt, cinnamon, allspice, and garlic to a blender. Puree until smooth and silky. Remove the skins and seeds from the squash and add the flesh to the blender. Remove the outer tough layer of skin from the onion and add the whole roasted onion to the blender. Puree with the cashew mixture until smooth. (I use my Blendtec. If your blender isn’t large, puree in batches - link for 20% off any blender with Blendtec coupon code: YAY-BLENDTEC). If more water is needed, add enough to loosen/thin the mixture and puree again. Transfer the mixture to a pot, scraping the blender with a spatula to loosen all the mixture. Gently heat the soup, season with extra salt if desired, and extra water to thin if you like, then serve. Serves 4.
Notes
What vegetables or fruits – or other plant foods – are you a little intimidated to try? Let me know, maybe I’ll choose one for my next video.
x Dreena
p.s. If you already have PPF and love this soup (or other recipes) please add a review to amazon, it’s so helpful. And a BIG thanks to all of you that have already shared a 5-start review. Thank you.



Rebecca Boehm says
This Delicious Soup was our plan “B” when we roasted butternut squash. Plan “B” has now become our favorite! This soup is creamy and smooth and satisfying! The combination of rosemary and cinnamon could not be more wonderfully surprising! The flavors are subtle and quite perfect. My husband and I worked together following the simple directions, we couldn’t use the cashews because a guest has tree nut allergies. I don’t see how cashews are needed, it was delectable without them. I have recently found you, Dreena, and have been successful and enjoyed each recipe that I have made. My husband is pleasantly surprised by how delicious eating plant based can be. Thank you!
Dreena says
Well, what a delightful note – thank you, Rebecca! I’m especially pleased you loved the soup without the added cashews. Sounds like plan B now is a plan A 🙂 Thanks for the cheer.
Rebecca Cody says
I notice you don’t say to pierce the squash a couple of times to release steam before baking. Last year I roasted two spaghetti squashes. The small one cooked done and worked just fine. The larger one exploded all over my oven because I hadn’t pierced it. Perhaps butternut squash wouldn’t explode, but I’m not taking chances again!
Dreena says
Hi Rebecca, I never pierce butternut squash, and haven’t ever had them explode. Ditto for sweet potatoes, in fact I find they ‘ooze’ too much when pierced. White potatoes, I do have to pierce (have had them explode)! I’ve only cooked spaghetti squash by first slicing, then inverting on a baking sheet. So, perhaps they might be different. I imagine that was quite a mess!!
Helen Hooper Butt says
This soup is delicious! I made it with buttercup squash and omitted the rosemary–not a fan of it. Also had some veggie broth on hand so used that. Really easy and tasty.
Dreena says
So glad to hear it, thanks Helen!
Jan says
You mentioned a tea in your video . Would you mind suppying link?
Dreena says
Oh, right! Thanks for reminding me – here it is: http://bit.ly/1oCkTkc
Mary says
gotta try this… looks so tasty. I got so many squash in my CSA this year… Im still going through them.
BTW, Dreena, your skin is gorgeous… it’s that plant powered beauty!